• tel
  • facebook
  • linkedin
  • youtube
  • emailinfo@innofluid.com
  • logo
  • Home
  • Product
    • Laboratory Peristaltic Pump
    • Industrial Peristaltic Pump
    • Explosion proof peristaltic pump
    • Dispensing and Filling Peristaltic Pump
    • Multi-Channel Independent Control System
    • ODM Fluid Handling Solution
    • OEM Pump and Pump Head
    • Tubing and Accessories
    • Liquid Filling Machine
    • Syringe Pump Series
  • Application
  • News
    •  
    • Company News
    • Exhibition News
    • Media Coverage
  • Support
  • About Us
  • contactus
  • EnglishEnglish ▼
    ChinaChina
    DeutschDeutsch
    АнглийскийАнглийский
    EnglishEnglish
  1. Home
  2. Company News
Peristaltic Pump vs Diaphragm Pump: Which Should You Choose? Accuracy, Solids, Upkeep?

Peristaltic pump vs diaphragm pump: which one is right for your line? A wrong pick can block parts, spoil doses and stop your work again and again.

Choose a peristaltic pump for clean, exact doses at low flow. It also works well with liquids that carry solids. Choose a diaphragm pump when your job needs valves and higher pressure. Your liquid, your dose and your pressure decide.

In this guide, you will learn how each pump works. You will also see how they differ in accuracy, solids, priming, pressure and upkeep. The Innofluid facts come from its own product pages.

How Each Pump Moves Liquid

A peristaltic pump moves liquid by squeezing a flexible tube with a roller.

How a peristaltic pump works

As the rotor spins, the tube is compressed by the roller. We move the liquid ahead by means of the roller. Only the interior of the tube comes into contact with the liquid.

A tube pump uses a small tube. Innofluid's HPM600G/GY15 is one example. A hose pump uses a bigger, thicker hose. Innofluid's SC series is its hose-type range for industry.

How a diaphragm pump works

The diaphragm pump is able to transfer liquids by use of a movable, reversible sheet. This flat layer is known as the diaphragm. As a result, the pump chamber expands and contracts. At the intake, a check valve allows liquid to enter. The liquid is released at the outlet by a check valve.

They are both pumps that use positive displacement. So, there's a constant volume of liquid expended with every motion. Each pump, however, directs the liquid in a completely different way.

Peristaltic Pump vs Diaphragm Pump: The Differences That Change Your Choice

The two pumps differ most in how the liquid flows, whether they use check valves, and how much care they need. Your peristaltic pump vs diaphragm pump choice comes down to seven points.

How the two pumps compare

Point

Peristaltic pump (Innofluid facts)

Diaphragm pump (how it works)

Liquid path

Liquid stays inside the tube or hose

Liquid fills a chamber and passes through valves

Check valves

SC-40 page: none needed

Inlet and outlet check valves

Metering accuracy

SC-40: ±1%

Stroke-based; depends on the valves

Solids handling

SC-40 page lists large solids and abrasive slurries

Solids can hold a valve open

Self-priming

SC-40: self-priming, suction lift up to 9.5 m

Priming depends on the valves

Pressure

HPM600G/GY15: max 0.8 MPa; SC series: 10–16 bar

Check the maker's rating for each model

Maintenance

SC-40: just change the hose

Diaphragm and valves need checks

The next sections explain each row.

Metering Accuracy and Chemical Dosing

The dosage is consistently delivered using a peristaltic pump that can be controlled by speed. In a fluid, the speed of the motor determines the flow. At constant velocity, the flow remains constant. Each dosage stays near the goal with a good tube and a new calibration.

Why speed control gives the same dose each time

The HPM600G/GY15 runs from 0.1 to 600 rpm. Its speed step is 0.01 rpm. Its flow range is 0.0255–513 mL/min.

The HPME-SS series lists flow as low as 0.0002 mL/min. This depends on the pump head.

Calibration and dosing modes

Calibration is automatic. You type in the volume the pump really moved.

The HPM600G/GY15 and the HP600/YZ35-II dispense from 0.1 mL to 9999 L.

The dosing modes are fixed volume, timed and speed.

The HPME-SS and HP600/YZ35-II list a 0–360° back suction angle.


Filling accuracy in numbers

The HP600/YZ35-II is listed at ±0.5% for fills of 50–500 mL. The 50 mL test used 26# tubing, a 1 s fill time and 428.6 rpm. The 500 mL test used two YZ35-II heads, 82# tubing and a 2 s fill time. Always keep the test setup next to the number. Without it, the number tells you little.

Where a diaphragm pump fits dosing

A diaphragm pump doses by stroke. Each stroke pushes liquid through the valves. So the dose depends on how well the valves work.

Solids, Thick Liquids and Why Check Valves Matter

Check valves matter because solids can hold them open. This is the main reason the two pumps differ in solids handling.

Where solids get stuck

A ball and a seat make up a check valve. If anything substantial gets wedged between them, the valve will remain open. As soon as the liquid returns, the dosage is deactivated. The liquid channel of a tube pump does not include a valve seat.

What the SC-40 can pump

Innofluid's SC-40 page lists abrasive slurries (rough, gritty mixes), corrosive acids, large solids and gaseous liquids. It also lists thick (high-viscosity) products and shear-sensitive ones, which rough handling can harm. The page says it needs no extra equipment and no check valves.

The tube must match the liquid

The tube is the limit. It must suit your liquid. Take Versilon F-5500-A from Saint-Gobain as an example. It has a hardness of Shore A 60. It works from -51 °C to 204 °C.

The tubing page says it resists corrosive chemicals, oils, fuels, solvents and most mineral acids. Check chemical resistance before you use any tube.

Self-Priming, Suction Lift and Dry Running

The ability to draw liquid from a lower tank without filling the pump first is known as self-priming. It can self-prime and has a suction lift capacity of up to 9.5 m, according to the SC-40 website. How much liquid a pump is able to suction is called its suction lift. Additionally, the website states that the pump may run dry without any time restriction or harm.

The SC hose-pump line is the only object of these assertions. They won't work with every tube pump. Bring up the topic of dry running and lift specifically for your model. Prime a diaphragm pump by opening its valves. Priming is therefore dependent on the efficiency of the valves.

Pressure and Flow Limits to Check First

Check the pressure limit first on a peristaltic pump.

Flow and pressure by model

Model

Flow

Pressure

HPM600G/GY15

0.0255–513 mL/min

max 0.8 MPa

HP600/YZ35-II

0.69–12000 mL/min

not listed

SC10

57 L/H

10 bar

SC40

3280 L/H

16 bar

Small dosing models and big transfer models are very different machines. Pick the model that fits your job. Write down your flow, pressure and tube size before you ask for a quote.

Tube Wear, Upkeep and Maintenance Cost

The tube wears out over time in a peristaltic pump. This is the main downside.

What shortens tube life

According to the Innofluid tube guide, there are five potential reasons: high pressure, fast speed, chemical interaction, high temperature, and lack of cleaning.

How these pumps cut downtime

HPM600G/GY15: it stops the pump at once when it finds a leak. It also has IP66 protection and three permission levels.

HPME-SS: it has a lid-open stop function. This depends on the pump head.

The HPM600G/GY15, HP600/YZ35-II and HPME-SS pages each list a 5-year warranty.

SC-40: it has no check valves and no sealing water flush system.


What drives maintenance cost

The price of the tube

How often you change it

Time lost to downtime

The cost of labor


Innofluid's site lists no prices or hours. Ask Innofluid for a quote for your tube size.

What a diaphragm pump asks for

A diaphragm pump has more inner parts to check. They are the diaphragm and the valves.

Where Each Pump Fits Best

A peristaltic pump is a good fit for clean filling and tough liquids.

Which pump for which job

Job

Likely fit

Reason

Pharma, biotech, cosmetic, food and beverage, diagnostic reagent filling

Peristaltic

Innofluid lists aseptic filling for these fields

Clean, hygienic work

HPME-SS

Stainless steel 304, designed to meet GMP requirements, easy to clean and disinfect

Corrosive chemical dosing

Tube material first, then pump

The tube touches the liquid

Slurry or solids-heavy transfer

SC series

SC-40 lists large solids and no check valves

For areas with a risk of explosion, see Innofluid's Explosion proof peristaltic pump range. For bottle work, see the Dispensing and Filling range.

Five Questions That Pick the Pump for You

Your answers to five questions settle the peristaltic pump vs diaphragm pump choice.

  1. What is in your liquid: solids, acid, thick or thin? (See the solids section.)

  2. How big is each dose, and how exact must it be? (See metering.)

  3. What pressure does your line need? (See pressure and flow limits.)

  4. Can the pump run dry, or must it pull from a low tank? (See self-priming.)

  5. Who will care for the pump, and how fast must a swap be done? (See tube wear.)

Take your answers to questions 1, 2 and 3 to Innofluid for a model match.

Mistakes That Cost Time and Tubes

Four small mistakes can cost you time and tubes.

Common mistakes

Using a tube that does not suit the chemical.

Not calibrating the pump after you change the tube.

Going past the pressure limit.

Having no plan to replace the tube. Change it before it fails completely.


FAQs

Which is better, a peristaltic or diaphragm pump?

No pump is ever going to be victorious. Make a decision based on your liquid, dosage accuracy, and pressure. For precise dosage, solids, and gaseous liquids, a peristaltic pump is the choice. Work involving clean fluid or higher-pressure valve operations are best suited for diaphragm pumps. Verify each item in light of the preceding sections.

What is the difference between a peristaltic pump and a diaphragm pump?

A peristaltic pump squeezes a rubber tube using its rollers. Liquid just comes into contact with the tube. Swinging back and forth, a diaphragm pump propels a diaphragm. There is a check valve at both the intake and the outlet that the liquid uses. Although the liquid paths are drastically different, both devices release the same volume of liquid.

What are the disadvantages of a peristaltic pump?

The tube is a wear part, so it needs a replacement plan. Pressure is also limited. The HPM600G/GY15 lists a maximum of 0.8 MPa. The tube must match the liquid too. Check the listed limits of each model before you buy.

What are the disadvantages of diaphragm pumps?

A diaphragm pump relies on valves. Solids can hold a valve open and upset the flow. It also has more parts to service, like the diaphragm and the valves. Both dose accuracy and priming depend on the state of the valves.

Which type of pump is best suited for consistent metering of liquids?

A peristaltic pump with speed control suits steady metering, because flow follows motor speed. The HPM600G/GY15 lists a 0.01 rpm speed step and automatic calibration. The HP600/YZ35-II lists ±0.5% on fills of 50–500 mL. The SC-40 page lists ±1% metering accuracy for larger flows.

Do peristaltic pumps need check valves?

No. A peristaltic pump has no valve seat in the liquid path. The SC-40 page says it needs no check valves, no extra equipment and no sealing water flush system. That removes a common spot where solids get stuck and doses drift.

Can a peristaltic pump run dry?

The SC-40 page says it can run dry indefinitely without damage. That claim is for the SC hose-pump line only. Do not assume it for other models. Ask Innofluid to confirm dry running for your exact model before you install it.

Conclusion

For peristaltic pump vs diaphragm pump, look at your liquid first, then your dose, then your pressure. Solids, exact doses and low flow point to a peristaltic pump. Clean liquid and jobs that run on valves point to a diaphragm pump.

Innofluid Co., Ltd. lists peristaltic and syringe pumps, not diaphragm pumps. See the full Industrial Peristaltic Pump range. Each model page lists its own specs. Check the numbers before buying. Then send your flow, pressure and tube size to info@innofluid.com for a model match.

 
logo
About Us

Company Profile
Product

Laboratory Peristaltic Pump
Industrial Peristaltic Pump
Explosion proof peristaltic pump
Dispensing and Filling Peristaltic Pump
Multi-Channel Independent Control System
ODM Fluid Handling Solution
OEM Pump and Pump Head
Tubing and Accessories
Liquid Filling Machine
Syringe Pump Series
Application

Laboratory application
Industry application
E Liquid Filling Pump
Filling Various Reagents
Support

Download

Contact

Innofluid Co., Ltd.
Add: Building 10, No. 860, Xinyang Road, Lingang New Area, Pilot Free Trade Zone, Shanghai, China
Zip Code:200135
Tel: +86-312-5958380
Website: http://www.innofluid.com
E-mail: info@innofluid.com
    Contact
    © 2023 申辰流体科技(上海)有限公司 | 沪ICP备2022015939号-2 | [Privacy Policy]

    We use cookies

    Our website uses cookies to enhance user experience, personalise content and show you more relevant adverts about our great products, also to analyze our website traffic.